What if your best employees aren’t burned out because they’re doing too much, but because they’re giving everything and getting nothing back?
Andrea Carter reveals why workplace belonging is more than fitting in, and how a lack of belonging can fuel exhaustion, disengagement, and turnover. She breaks belonging down into five measurable indicators and shares six practical actions leaders can take to build trust, strengthen psychological safety, and help people do their best work.
Listen to the end to discover why your top performers may be at risk when they’re always the ones giving 100% and receiving nothing in return.
What you will learn from this episode:
- Learn the five indicators of workplace belonging and how they influence engagement, innovation, and retention.
- Discover why fitting in isn’t the same as belonging, and how a lack of reciprocity can lead to burnout.
- Discover six practical ways to make belonging measurable and build a healthier, more engaged workplace.
“You regulate or dysregulate any room you walk into.”
– Andrea Carter
Topics Covered:
01:15 – What workplace belonging really means: Andrea explains the five indicators that create the conditions for people to feel safe, valued, and able to contribute.
04:45 – How to measure belonging: Learn how organizations can identify belonging gaps instead of relying on averages that may hide employees who feel excluded.
06:15 – Why employees feel exhausted and disconnected: Andrea explains how giving 100% to support others without receiving support in return can contribute to chronic stress.
08:30 – How leaders influence the room: Discover why clarity, predictability, and clear expectations can help employees feel more comfortable and work at their best.
10:00 – The five indicators in action: Learn how comfort, connection, contribution, psychological safety, and well-being work together to strengthen teams.
11:15 – Why resilience isn’t a solo sport: Andrea explains why women leaders need supportive networks and must learn to receive help, not just give it.
13:00 – Why women struggle to ask for what they need: Explore the workplace expectations that can discourage women from speaking up, seeking support, and advocating for themselves.
17:00 – Six ways leaders can increase belonging: Andrea shares practical actions, from measuring belonging gaps and closing the feedback loop to making contributions visible.
22:00 – Protecting boundaries and well-being: Discover why leaders should check team capacity, normalize recovery, and avoid creating a culture of constant availability.
24:00 – The 50/50 framework for belonging: Learn why healthy teams require a balance of giving and receiving, and why leaders should intervene when some people continually give without support.
26:00 – Why consistent contributors matter: Andrea explains why teams need more than top performers and how an unhealthy team culture can spread when people feel overburdened.
Key Takeaways:
“Belonging is actually a shared responsibility and a shared accountability.” – Andrea Carter
“That exhaustion isn’t weakness. That exhaustion is actually your nervous system in chronic stress because the infrastructure isn’t reciprocated.” – Andrea Carter
“Resilience is not a solo sport.” – Andrea Carter
“People need to know that they can speak up without punishment.” – Andrea Carter
“Opting out is not a tool.” – Andrea Carter
“You can’t always be the person who is giving. You need to be receiving.” – Andrea Carter
Resources Mentioned:
- Belonging Breakdown: A five-minute diagnostic to help individuals identify where giving and receiving may be breaking down in their relationships. Visit Belonging First and look for the Belonging Breakdown.
- The Devil Emails at Midnight: A book Andrea mentions about archetypes of bad bosses.
Ways to Connect with Andrea Carter:
- Website: https://belongingfirst.com/
- Belonging Health Check: 5 Minutes to Find Out If Belonging Is Fragile https://belongingfirst.com/belongingbreakdown/
Ways to Connect with Sarah E. Brown:
- Website: https://www.sarahebrown.com
- Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/DrSarahEBrown
- LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/sarahebrownphd
- To speak with her: bookachatwithsarahebrown.com
Full Episode Transcript:
(AI helped us put this together, so if you see any weird grammar or missed words—just know we nailed it during the actual chat.)
Andrea Carter
What most people think of when they’re in an environment is a fitting in scenario, which is where 100% of your acceptability and your ability to contribute relies on you being 100% in alignment with everybody else.
Whereas belonging is actually a shared responsibility and a shared accountability. It means that everyone is giving 50% and they’re also receiving 50% back.
Sarah E. Brown
Hello everyone. Welcome to the KTS Success Factor podcast for women, where we talk about challenges senior female leaders face in being happy and successful at work. I’m your host, Dr. Sarah E. Brown.
My guest today is Andrea Carter.
She’s led one of the largest belonging studies in Canadian mining, with her validated approach making measurable impact across eight industries and over 150,000 employees, cutting toxicity and belonging gaps by 24% on average.
As an adjunct professor at Adler University, Andrea translates complex neuroscience and intersection identity analysis into actionable frameworks for HR, people, and culture leaders, and executives wrestling with trust, retention, and the high cost of burnout.
Andrea’s practical insights on measurable belonging, psychological safety, and production friction are what we’re going to be talking about today.
And I should also mention that she is the founder of Andrea Carter Consulting.
So, welcome, Andrea. I’m excited to have this conversation.
Andrea Carter
Thank you, Sarah, and thanks for the kind introduction, and I’m excited to have this conversation with you.
Sarah E. Brown
So let’s start off with what is belonging?
Andrea Carter
You bet. So belonging is actually the science that you can feel when five indicators exist together, and those indicators are comfort, connection, contribution, psychological safety, and well-being.
And when these five are present, they actually create an infrastructure that produces engagement, speed, quality, innovation, retention, and renewal.
Despite friction, which friction right now is like constant tidal waves hitting us in all sorts of different direction.
So each indicator has a function.
Comfort calms, calms the system through clarity and predictability.
Connection bonds the system through trust.
Contribution activates the system. You know you matter, which means that it motivates and mobilizes you to work well with others. Psychological safety protects the system, meaning you can speak, try, fail, and challenge without that fear of social punishment.
And wellbeing actually renews the system through collective resilience, and we’ll speak more about that after, but right now we have to rebalance how we’re thinking about resilience and bouncing back.
Sarah E. Brown
Okay. I just have to ask, does everybody feel comfort the same way?
Andrea Carter
So comfort is measured through clarity, predictability, and knowing what the success factors are.
When you have those three elements, what happens to your brain is that it helps your brain regulate and calm yourself down so that you can actually be at your best self.
When you don’t feel comfortable and you don’t have those three things, your brain is actually in protection mode.
Sarah E. Brown
Okay. All right, so in essence, everybody has the same barometer, so to speak, on comfort when you define it that way with those factors?
Andrea Carter
Yes.
Sarah E. Brown
Okay.
Andrea Carter
So comfort isn’t like being nice. It’s not having a lack of friction or conflict. It’s literally that you can see those predictability elements. You know what to expect. There’s clarity around your expectations and then the expectations of others.
Sarah E. Brown
Okay. Now, I know you got more to say about this, but I just gotta clarify some of these points. So contribution, is that individual contribution or is it what the system is producing?
Andrea Carter
Yeah, so belonging is very different from fitting in. What most people think of when they’re in an environment is a fitting in scenario, which is where 100% of your acceptability and your ability to contribute relies on you being 100% in alignment with everybody else.
Sarah E. Brown
Hmm.
Andrea Carter
Whereas belonging is actually a shared responsibility and a shared accountability. It means that everyone is giving 50% and they’re also receiving 50% back, and there’s always somebody who is supporting the regulation of that to ensure that there is both give and take.
When it’s only 100% you and 0% of the environment, that’s belonging, not fitting in. So these indicators have both elements where you are contributing and then also where you are receiving.
Sarah E. Brown
Okay. How do you measure these things?
Andrea Carter
Well, we actually, this is where I started. That was my initial element because what we found was that people were using the word belonging in a very, like, feeling sense that made it almost esoteric and, like, really unable to measure.
And so the first thing that we started with were how do we actually measure belonging? And that’s where we came up with those five validated indicators to start with.
So again, comfort, connection, contribution, psychological safety, wellbeing.
And there are five questions per indicator that allows us to measure it within an organization.
But here’s the critical piece. When they’re being measured, we actually look at multiplicative analysis to understand which identity indicators are statistically relevant first, and then we look at which of those indicators are mediating or driving the gap.
Most survey analysis looks at the average, and in looking at the average, you’re actually silencing the people who don’t actually feel that they belong.
And so that’s where when we measure those gaps in the organization, we can see that 24% reduction in belonging gaps, 18% increase in engagement, and typically a 16% reduction in turnover.
So what I will say is that this isn’t just an organizational tool. So this year we’ve also launched a tool for individuals called the ‘Belonging Breakdown’, and it’s a five-minute diagnostic that really shows where your own impact of what you’re giving and what you’re receiving is breaking down in key relationships.
So you can measure, you know, are you dysregulating and struggling to give your 50% in belonging, or how are people showing up for you?
And that’s really a great starting place because most people think they’re waiting for people to give belonging to them first, when often we also have shared elements that we are sometimes doing that we don’t even realize that we’re doing, creating that dysregulation in relationships.
Sarah E. Brown
Is that diagnostic available for my listeners too?
Andrea Carter
I certainly will provide that to your listeners, Sarah, absolutely.
Sarah E. Brown
That’s a very intriguing tool, actually. Mm-hmm.
Andrea Carter
Sure. So you can actually go to the belonging, belongingfirst.com, and then I believe it’s /belongingbreakdown is the URL
Sarah E. Brown
Okay. And that will be in the show notes.
Andrea Carter
You bet.
Sarah E. Brown
Okay, great. So pretty complex tool here.
Andrea Carter
How did you get started doing this? Well, there was actually multiple factors, but let me start. 10 years ago, I was coaching, you know, technically brilliant leaders of teams who we were seeing a lot of quiet quitting. We were seeing a lot of people saying, “I don’t belong here.I’m exhausted. I can’t thrive here.”
And what we were realizing was that word belonging was being used repetitively, and people not feeling like they belonged.
So that was 10 years ago. That was also when we started doing the research on DEI and whether DEI would actually bring people together or polarize people, and the research actually showed it would polarize people.
Sarah E. Brown
Hmm.
Andrea Carter
And so we went on kind of this neuroscience journey first of looking at what actually allows people to feel belonging.
And then five years ago, during, right before COVID hit, I decided I wanted to look at how we could measure the indicators from neuroscience into organizational lens.
And so I went back and I did a master’s in industrial and organizational psychology.
Sarah E. Brown
Mm-hmm.
Andrea Carter
And what we realized in our initial research was that many people who were saying, “I don’t belong here. I’m exhausted,” it’s because they were giving 100% building culture, you know, providing psychological safety, connection, or comfort for others, but they weren’t getting anything back.
And on top of that, they weren’t feeling valued, so contribution of how people were able to be valued for them being who they are, but then also for their work, was really not showing up. And so they were fitting in, they weren’t belonging.
And that exhaustion, that exhaustion isn’t weakness. That exhaustion is actually your nervous system in chronic stress because the infrastructure isn’t reciprocated.
And then what happened was I had two children who are also neurodivergent, and they were in the public school system at the time, which is not structured for children who are neurodivergent.
And I recognized that we needed to start doing something different for our families, for our communities, for our schools, and then within the organizational level as well.
Sarah E. Brown
Since you brought it up, I know what it means. I didn’t mean that to be haughty, but for my listeners, define neurodivergence so that they know what you’re talking about there.
Andrea Carter
You bet. So neurodivergent is almost like an umbrella term, and it essentially brings in everything from autistic, ADHD, ADD, anxiety, depression on the other spectrum, and then also even dyslexia.
So if you think of neurotypical, that is the brains that work well within our-
Sarah E. Brown
Public school system.
Andrea Carter
Our public school system. Exactly. Exactly. Yeah. Yeah. And it’s because it’s, you know, you can memorize things easily. You, you know, have the ability to regurgitate information.
You essentially can fit within a mold very easy. You’re in the average section, and anybody who is outside of that, their brains just are wired differently.
The cool part about neurodivergent people is that their brains actually work multifaceted, so they feel things deeply. They pick up on information faster. Their senses actually run often in multiple levels.
So imagine that your sensory information isn’t just like smelling something. It’s like smelling, hearing, touching, and all three of those things are wired together.
Sarah E. Brown
Mm-hmm.
Andrea Carter
So they’re just… Their brains process in a different way. But neurodivergent people, I think, are part of what will heal our future.
Sarah E. Brown
Agreed on that. But I wanna go back to this belonging thing. So if I am an employee, a female executive who’s listening to this, I probably have a sense of where I fit on the belonging scale or how it’s working for me by whether or not I’m tired and stressed and go home at night, when I go home at night.
And you just gave us an indication of a diagnostic that they can use to verify that. But if I’m a leader of an organization, I don’t necessarily have insight into the heads of the people that are in my organization.
So how do I determine where I stack up?
Andrea Carter
Yeah. So what’s interesting about belonging is that if you’re a leader, and this is the thing that I will always tell leaders, you regulate or dysregulate any room you walk into.
So if you are not aware of how you’re providing clarity, predictability, success factors to your employees, that means you don’t know off the top of your head whether or not you’re creating calm, which eases friction and actually allows people to work at their best selves, or if you’re dysregulating people, which is actually gonna decrease their ability to work at an optimal pace, at an optimal level, and do the things that they need to get done.
So that’s just from a comfort perspective. That diagnostic tool-
Sarah E. Brown
So let’s go through those three points again, the three things that leaders have to do every time they walk in the room.
Andrea Carter
So from a, just from a comfort lens-
Sarah E. Brown
Correct …
Andrea Carter
…just from a comfort lens, they have to understand if they’re being clear.
Sarah E. Brown
Clear. Clear about the objective, right?
Andrea Carter:
Clear about the objectives. The other thing they wanna be clear on is imagine that there’s changes, okay? There’s cha- so much change right now. You need to know what isn’t changing.
Sarah E. Brown
Mm-hmm.
Andrea Carter
Cause what isn’t changing is gonna anchor your people. So that clarity of what you know versus what you don’t know, when you anchor it in what you know, that actually creates more ease for people.
That takes people’s brains out of dysregulation.
Sarah E. Brown
Mm-hmm.
Andrea Carter
So clarity, predictability, and you have to be able to provide people with what you expect and what is expected of you.
Sarah E. Brown
Okay. Got it. Mm-hmm.
Andrea Carter
So here’s a really great way to think about this. Belonging is present when the nervous system is actually able to rest and not be scanning constantly for threat.
What that means is you have clarity about what’s expected. That’s comfort. We just talked about that. Comfort calms you. You’re known and you’re understood.
It means that your relationships have trust, and they are beyond transactional. That’s connection. It bonds you.
Sarah E. Brown
Mm-hmm.
Andrea Carter
Your work matters, and people tell you, “I need your opinion.I want your opinion. Here’s what I’m thinking.”
Contribution activates you. It gets people motivated. It gets people mobilized. It brings people together. You move through friction with contribution.
Sarah E. Brown
Mm-hmm.
Andrea Carter
People need to know that they can speak up without punishment. So speak up, try, admit, challenge, all of those things, without social punishment.
And then well-being is what actually renews you. And that is where there’s consideration, there’s compassion.
And resilience is not a solo sport. We know this. If you look at any of the data based on things like Hurricane Katrina, any of the hurricanes where there have been people that have had to rebuild from nothing, COVID, you are able to bounce back.
Resilience relies on the social networks and the people that surround you.
And if you have those, you will recover 40% to 60% faster than somebody who is on their own. The reason that is so important for female leaders is that female leaders have often been conditioned to be self-starters, to go it alone, to not rely on people.
And so this piece is actually a really critical piece for women. We need to build networks. We need to build community, and you can’t always be the person who is giving. You need to be receiving, and when you receive, you actually need to open yourself to receiving.
Sarah E. Brown
Okay, so where does this female leader, because this is my story, but it’s also what I’m speaking to my audience, seldom has female peers. She often has male peers, but how does she go about building that network?
Advertisement
Hi, this is Sarah Brown again, the host of the KTS Success Factor podcast for women. I hope you are enjoying this episode and gaining some tips and inspiration on how you can be happier, more successful, and experience less stress at work. If you would like to learn more about how you can empower the women in your organization to do the same, simply click on the show notes to see how you can connect with me.
As an added bonus for my podcast guests, you will see how you can book 30 minutes with me to explore how you can implement a scalable self-coaching program for the women in your organization. Simply visit bookachatwithsarahbrown.com.
Now back to this informative episode.
Andrea Carter
Yeah, and so the network comes in in many different fashions, if you will. And so what I want you to think about is that it doesn’t necessarily have to be directly with the people that are in your work. You can build with similar function or similar industry leaders as well. The big thing you want to think about, and this happens with women and it happens with men.
If you are able to start giving and showing up in a belonging way where you’re using those five indicators, what happens is that you then become better at also being able to give feedback on what you need and articulating what you need.
So one of the things that’s very fascinating about women is that women aren’t necessarily as eloquent at being able to share what they need in order for them to be successful. And so with that-
Sarah E. Brown
And I will add they don’t even know what they need to be successful.
Andrea Carter
There is that, right? And so when we go into…
What’s fascinating right now is we actually have a bit of a three-dimensional epidemic that’s happening. We have the most lonely society we have ever had in history. The data is outrageous.
I’m not gonna waste time on data right now, but loneliness, toxicity is at 80% globally. It was 66% last year, so we’re up 14%, and we have the most estrangement and lack of trust in our communities, in our governments, and in our families.
So when you think of women, what have women been taught over the past five years
Sarah E. Brown
Take care of others, not yourself. Keep your mouth closed. If you do extraordinary work, you will be recognized. Don’t promote yourself.
Certainly don’t ask for things because you’ll come across as needy. Is that enough?
Andrea Carter
So yes. All of those are certainly in play, certainly, and they all ring true.
Here’s what we’re seeing in our social media today, the rules for 2026 to stop letting everything affect you.
This is what women are being told: call who calls you, visit who visits you, ignore who ignores you.
How do you think that’s setting women up, women leaders up, to, A, create belonging environments where people are actually engaged, where people are actually able to be quick, produce quality, be innovative, and keep their people?
How do you think that is actually driving women to go further away from belonging?
Sarah E. Brown
For themselves and for their organizations, for both.
Andrea Carter
Totally. Mm-hmm. 100%.
Sarah E. Brown
Mm-hmm.
Andrea Carter
100%. And so when we look at this, you know, and even if you look at, like Mel Robbins, who came out with her Let Them theory, that is actually driving more divisiveness.
Sarah E. Brown
Why, why do you say that? For those of you who have not read the book, the whole idea of Mel Robbins’ premise is stop resisting what other people are doing and just let them do whatever- Let them
Andrea Carter
be them …
Sarah E. Brown
Let them be who they are, let them do what they’re doing, don’t resist it, and then you figure out what you’re gonna do about it.
So I wanna say why… I want your perspective on why that’s divisive.
Andrea Carter
Absolutely. It’s because it puts your nervous system still in a state of threat, which means that you are then responding from a state of threat. You’re gonna double down, you’re gonna defend, you’re going to fight or flight. You’re gonna opt out.
So if you think back to, like the very common fight, flight, freeze or faint, those are the four things that you’re stuck in if that’s the element that you’re working through.
Whereas if you’re using a belonging first mentality, it means that you’re looking at when friction hits, you’re looking for ways to move through it productively so that you don’t go into that fight, flight, freeze or shut down.
And so each of these indicators, comfort gives you the ease to actually handle the friction when it occurs, connection gives you the trust that the friction, you’ll navigate it together, contribution helps you move through the friction itself so you’re both showing up, psychological safety protects you through the friction, and then wellbeing is what’s actually helping you bounce back- and stay engaged through that friction.
When we disengage, we’re actually harming not only ourselves, but our ability to move through conflict, and there’s so much conflict right now. We actually need tools, and opting out is not a tool.
Sarah E. Brown
So I would think that just keeping these five factors in mind as you walk into a room, like if you had just a little, this is old school, three by five card with the five written down, and you go-
“Okay, what’s, what’s the comfort level? What’s my degree of connection, and what do I think is happening or in the room, and can I sense whether or not there is safety? Are people actually voicing things?”
I would think just keeping those five things in mind would be a real jumpstart.
Andrea Carter
Absolutely. 100%. Okay.
And you can even look at, you know… It’s really interesting when you look at people who feel uncomfortable. It’s easy to identify who feels uncomfortable in a room.
So if you see somebody who doesn’t feel comfort, and you see somebody who’s, you know, leaning back or leaning out, and I’m just using comfort just because it’s the first indicator and it’s easy.
The first thing that you can say is, “I think that you’re gonna name it. I can see that maybe things aren’t as clear as you’d like them to be. How might I clarify this better for you?
What is it that you’re missing? What is it that you might need so that I can ensure that you feel that this is predictable for you?”
Sarah E. Brown
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Got it. So Andrea, what did I not ask you that I should have that would help my audience understand belonging and what they can do about it?
Andrea Carter
Well, that’s such a great question. I would say maybe as a leader, what are the six things that you can do in order for you to acknowledge belonging?
So measure your five indicators, and then look for the gap between groups, and that’s where your system is failing. That’s where you wanna start.
The second is close the loop on feedback publicly. Last week, someone raised this question, raised this as a flag. Here’s either what we’re going to do, or here’s what we did.
Make sure that you name who raised that and why it’s a positive. Okay? People see that their voice matters and that there’s work that’s being done. They had influence.
Make contribution visible, so acknowledge the work in the moment publicly.
Name the impact, not just the outcome. Respond to difference, pushback, challenge. Respond with curiosity.
Instead of getting defensive, I want you to start saying, “Tell me more about what that really means. What is it that I’m missing here?”
Because how you show up in that moment of challenge, if you dysregulate in that moment, they also will dysregulate. But if you remain curious and regulated and open, you’re modeling that challenge is valued and not dangerous. Protect boundaries and model wellbeing.
What I mean by this, check your capacity before adding work.
So- what leaders often will do is there’s change, we have to evolve, and all of the sudden there’s all of these different initiatives. What you wanna do is look at what the capacity is and plan it, map it.
Where does it actually make sense, instead of having that knee-jerk reaction?
Don’t email at midnight- … and then normalize recovery. The reason I say don’t email at, at midnight, there’s actually a really great colleague that I have who actually just published a book called The Devil Emails at Midnight. It’s a fantastic book. It’s basically about all the archetypes of bad bosses.
But here’s the thing. When we don’t protect boundaries and we don’t model wellbeing, and even though it’s convenient for us to do things like emailing at midnight, because guess what? That’s when our kids are in bed. That’s typically where we’re catching up on work, and I know that, you know, my 10:00 PM to midnight writing time is ideal for me.
But we also have these wonderful things with technology now. You can set your email to send in the morning during business hours, and that’s not just protecting you. That’s actually protecting your people so that you’re giving them 50% to normalize recovery time as well.
If that’s what you need back, that’s what you’re gonna give back.
Sarah E. Brown
Mm-hmm.
Andrea Carter
And then the sixth is really simple, regulate the 50/50 framework.
So look at where you’re ensuring that everyone is giving and receiving, and then there isn’t one specific person that’s always 100% without zero back.
And when groups are giving 100% and receiving zero, intervene.
Your top performers, I just had a really great conversation on a, on a different podcast about how employees are…unfortunately right now, there’s a lot of downsizing, and typically what happens is that leaders look at who are their top performers, and they’re gonna keep their A’s, maybe some of their B’s, and they’re getting rid of half of their B’s and all of their C’s. If you look at team sports, that is not how teams win.
Your As, your Bs, and your Cs all play a part, and the people who are giving 50%, they may not be giving 110% every single day, but maybe they’re consistent in giving 75% every single day.
Those people who are consistent are often better than your top performers because what I can tell you is mold spreads really quickly, and if you have one bad apple who is tired of always doing everything, that spreads like wildfire or mold in a bowl.
Sarah E. Brown
Okay, so let me run them. Measure the five indicators, close the loop on feedback publicly.
Andrea Carter
Yep.
Sarah E. Brown
Make contributions visible, respond to differences with curiosity, protect boundaries, and regulate that 50/50 split.
Andrea Carter
You bet.
Sarah E. Brown
Great. Andrea, thank you for being with me.
Andrea Carter
Thanks for having me, Sarah.
Sarah E. Brown
Thanks for listening to the KTS Success Factor podcast for women.
If you like what you are hearing, please go to iTunes to subscribe, rate us, and leave a review. And if you would like more information on how we can help women in your organization to thrive, then go to www.sarahibrown.com.
You can sign up for our newsletter, read show notes, and learn more about our podcast guests, read my blog, browse through the books, or contact us for a chat.
Goodbye for now.